MADDIE’S SECRET (DIR. JOHN EARLY)

John Early’s debut feature is an era-defining triumph. Funny and sweet and over the top but also grounded and human and real. HOW IS THIS FILM POSSIBLE? The only one who knows is John Early himself…

Screened by the highest of highest Belfast tastemaker, and our best friend, NORMAL CINEMA CLUB, Maddie’s Secret follows the titular Maddie, a dishwasher at a content-creation kitchen, who dreams of more. She dreams of being the “vegetarian Nigella”, of having her own content series, of bringing the joy of vegan cooking and umami flavours to the wider public. However, when Maddie’s wishes come true, everything isn’t as she hoped. The pressures of being an online presence, coupled with an old eating disorder back from her past, Maddie crumbles, ending up in an almost psychosexual nightmare. Finally, Maddie collapses, is brought to a treatment facility, and her life almost falls apart totally.


The film teeters between outright comedy and heartbreaking sadness, though it never stumbles, never even places a toe out of line. Less of a parody and more of a loving tribute to the melodramas of the 50s, and straight-to-TV movies of the 80s and 90s, Maddie’s Secret understands exactly what made these films funny, in the overdramatic moments, the out-of-place eroticism, and also what made them heartbreaking. They pull from real situations, such as an eating disorder, and push it to the limit. This film is thus, the peak of the genre, whilst being something new entirely. There’s traces of John Waters here, in that Polyester was a melodrama like that of Douglas Sirk, and with John Early’s performance offering the same earnestness as Divine playing Francine Fishpaw.

Despite being one of the funniest films in recent memory, Maddie’s Secret never actually laughs at Maddie, or at the fact she’s being played by John Early himself. There’s no jokes about her condition, or the people with similar struggles at the treatment facility. The humour is always directed elsewhere, at the absurdity of a content-creation-test-kitchen or simply just at the conventions of the melodrama. This, in part, comes down to Early’s performance. He has written, and he plays Maddie with so much love and so much care and so much genuinely sincerity that he entirely disappears into the role. She has been meticulously crafted as the “perfect” “normal” girl. Her outfits, her hair, her down-to-earth personality, every last detail has been thought out and perfected. Her struggles have also been thoroughly explored, and John Early treats these issues with such a tenderness that there is no room for humour. Watching Maddie fall back into her old habits is heartbreaking, watching her refuse help is heartbreaking, watching her suffer is heartbreaking, and the film is not afraid of this. These are real situations that real people go through, and in real life they aren’t funny, they are heartbreaking. There is no irony here, no cynicism.

Beyond Early himself, this film is filled to the brim with outstanding performances by alt-comedy figureheads and legends. His longtime comedy partner, Kate Berlant shines as Maddie’s rulebreaking, risk taking, lesbian best friend, Deena, who helps bring Maddie out of her shell, but in the end, almost ruins Maddie’s recovery. There’s Eric Rahill as, sure we’ll say it, Maddie’s extremely sexy, always supportive husband. Conner O’Malley as the cartoonishly evil overlord of the content-creation kitchen, and paired up with Claudia O’Doherty, also cartoonishly evil, but this time with a redemption-arc, as Maddie’s online-chef-personality mean girl idol turned rival. These are, to name but a few stand-out performances, every single person in this film is operating at such a high-calibre they should all be Oscar nominees. As much as Maddie is fully understood, so is each of these characters, their roles and their classic tropes if this was a traditional melodrama, what makes them funny, and what makes them real.


Combine the amazing performances, writing and direction with hazy, dreamlike visuals, and this might just be a perfect movie. It is a perfect movie, to us. This feels like a film that will instantly enter the cinematic canon, a perfect embodiment of the current cultural zeitgeist, whilst being one-of-a-kind across almost every level.

In fifty years, when John Early has won five hundred Oscars, we’ll all look back and say “WOW! Maddie’s Secret was his DEBUT? He was already that good with his first feature?” And so on, and so forth.

WATCH THIS MOVIE IMMEDIATELY OR BE LEFT BEHIND.

THANK YOU TO NORMAL CINEMA CLUB FOR ONCE AGAIN BRINGING GREAT CINEMA TO THE PLACE THAT NEEDS IT MOST… BELFAST.

Previous
Previous

SHORTS SHORTS AND MORE SHORTS